MUFF WIGGLER Forum Index
 FAQ & Terms of UseFAQ & Terms Of Use   Wiggler RadioMW Radio   Muff Wiggler TwitterTwitter   Support the site @ PatreonPatreon 
 SearchSearch   RegisterSign up   Log inLog in 
WIGGLING 'LITE' IN GUEST MODE

Trapezoid VCO
MUFF WIGGLER Forum Index -> Music Tech DIY Goto page 1, 2  Next [all]
Author Trapezoid VCO
Haralds:Werk
I am working on a trapezoid VCO on the basis from Don Tillman's article from July 2003. I have made some changes but kept the basic architecture as given in his block diagram. I replaced the exponentiator circuitry and changed the control for the address line. So far I have a have a (faulty) PCB for the core. After some debugging I got it running. All four trapezoid outputs and the thru zero FM.

The next Version PCB for the core is on its way and will include a LFO switch and the quadrature square wave outputs. The wave shaper for triangle, sine, pulse andramp up/down is still in breadboard mode bit looks promising.







Jarno
Interesting VCO, I take it you did not use the 3280 OTA? Regular LM13700?

The article:
http://www.till.com/articles/QuadTrapVCO/discussion.html
http://www.till.com/articles/QuadTrapVCO/vcocore.html
dksynth
very interested to see this!
BugBrand
Jarno wrote:
Interesting VCO, I take it you did not use the 3280 OTA? Regular LM13700?


Sure Harald will comment, but Alfa remade the 3280 recently: http://www.alfarzpp.lv/eng/sc/AS3280.php
Haralds:Werk
Jarno wrote:
Interesting VCO, I take it you did not use the 3280 OTA? Regular LM13700?

The article:
http://www.till.com/articles/QuadTrapVCO/discussion.html
http://www.till.com/articles/QuadTrapVCO/vcocore.html


Thank you for the links to the original articles. I have forgotten them in my first post.

I am using the 3280 OTA and the SSM2220 matched pair in this design. I have some NOS of both around and want to use them up. The SSM2220 is easily replaced with a hand matched transistor pair and the 3280 is available again as AS3280 as stated above. I have no AS3280 to check if it is a drop in replacement though.

Using the LM13700 might be possible but I suspect some loss in performance quality. It should be an easy change with some adaption in the Iabc (exponentiator) and a few other resistor changes. And a new PCB of course.
dot matrix madness
Does somebody own the Doepfer A-110-6 Trapezoid VCO and would check which chips and OTAs they use?
cygmu
Good point! I don't have one, but there are some photos here:
https://www.thomannmusic.com/doepfer_a_110_6.htm

There is a V2164 in there.
Haralds:Werk
dot matrix madness wrote:
Does somebody own the Doepfer A-110-6 Trapezoid VCO and would check which chips and OTAs they use?


A quick search on the net reveals this one:
http://www.doepfer.de/a100_man/A110_6_trimming_potentiometers_and_jump ers.pdf
You can see Doepfer is using LM393N, DG409DJ, LF374 and SSM2164. So we can assume that they have replaced the 3280 with the SSM2164.
Haralds:Werk
dksynth wrote:
very interested to see this!


It is still an ongoing project. I have a first PCB for the core (the red one in the picture) the second one is already shipped from the vendor and should arrive this week. The waveshaper is partly in breadboard mode. A first PCB for the waveshapers should be ready in two or three weeks.

guest
hey Heralds:Werk, this is a bit off topic, but i just wanted to say that i appreciate your industriousness, attention to detail, and that you share your work here. its great following along with all the stuff youre making.
dksynth
Same sentiment here as from guest, haraldswerk has been bookmarked in my home computer for quite awhile. Your write ups are great!

Curious as to what you changed in the address bits, seems to me that’s where you’d adjust things to modify phase? The further info on how to do that never got written up.

I’m going to spin up a version with the 2164 cells, see what I can manage!
Haralds:Werk
guest wrote:
hey Heralds:Werk, this is a bit off topic, but i just wanted to say that i appreciate your industriousness, attention to detail, and that you share your work here. its great following along with all the stuff youre making.


Thank you. Every feedback is welcome. That keeps me publishing. Feedback is often scarce. I also appreciate critical feedback, questions and suggestions to improve my designs.
cygmu
Haralds:Werk wrote:
Every feedback is welcome. That keeps me publishing. Feedback is often scarce. I also appreciate critical feedback, questions and suggestions to improve my designs.


I always feel bad not saying anything in your threads, because I enjoy them a great deal, but don't have anything much to add, given that your work is so accomplished and well executed.

I have been intrigued by this Tillman design for a long time so I am very keen to see how this one develops. If anyone can figure out how to implement the voltage controlled phase shift that is referred to in the original article but never written up I will be very excited!

I asked about it here
http://www.muffwiggler.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=203284
but I don't think there was a conclusion. I also asked Don Tillman who said he didn't want to reveal the secrets because he was planning to commercialise the design (this was after the Doepfer appeared) so perhaps we shouldn't try to figure it out, but I am sooo curious...
djthopa
Great work as always, and very kind from you to openly share your projects! we're not worthy
Haralds:Werk
dksynth wrote:

I’m going to spin up a version with the 2164 cells, see what I can manage!


The 2146 should work, Doepfer is using it. If you start building from the original Tillman schematic have a close look to the voltages at the EN pin and the address lines A0/A1 of the DG409. And check the value of the pull up resistors.
Haralds:Werk
cygmu wrote:


I always feel bad not saying anything in your threads, because I enjoy them a great deal, but don't have anything much to add, given that your work is so accomplished and well executed.


Thank you for this remark. It got me thinking. I show the same behavior. In most cases when reading interesting threads I think "fine work" but did not comment if I have nothing substantial to add. I don't want to add chatter.

cygmu wrote:

I have been intrigued by this Tillman design for a long time so I am very keen to see how this one develops. If anyone can figure out how to implement the voltage controlled phase shift that is referred to in the original article but never written up I will be very excited!


Back on topic. I have an idea how to add it. But before diving into it I first want to have a stable running version of the core and the waveshapers. So far I have the usual triangle, sine, ramp up/down, square and pulse. But I stumbled over a lot of interesting wave forms while tinkering with adding / subtracting / mixing the above. Maybe I should add sort of a patch/mix section for experiments.

The second run off PCB's for the core arrived today. I'll stuff them over the weekend.
Haralds:Werk
So, the second PCB was populated and tested. I had to correct a newly introduced error and ran int some subtle timing problems with the comparators. It was strange. Turning the thru zero FM pot to one side everything worked fine. On the other side the oscillation first gets weird and then stops all together. Took me some time to fix that. Now I am waiting for the next PCB run. Meanwhile, for those who are interested what I am talking about: Here is the draft of the circuitry.
diablojoy
Hmm nice progress been meaning to try out this circuit for a while.
about the only thing I don't actually have on hand is any TL052's .
LektroiD
This looks like a really interesting oscillator. If PCBs & panels become available, please count me in...
Haralds:Werk
diablojoy wrote:
Hmm nice progress been meaning to try out this circuit for a while.
about the only thing I don't actually have on hand is any TL052's .


I tried the TL052 because I want something faster then the original used LF412. This VCO is still in draft mode and I'll decide what OpAmp's to use when the final version is running. The next PCB should arrive this week. You can use the LF412 or TL062 for testing as well. If you use OpAmp's with higher power consumption you'll need to replace the LM317L/LM337L with LM317/LM337 in TO220 package. Note, this is only page one of two. The circuitry for the square output is not shown. I'll build two versions and the swap the OpAmp's around to have a direct comparison.
Haralds:Werk
LektroiD wrote:
This looks like a really interesting oscillator. If PCBs & panels become available, please count me in...


For the moment I build this one for my 15V banana system. When I've got everything running I'll ask if there is some demand for a Eurorack version.
diablojoy
ahh cool good to know thanks thumbs up
Haralds:Werk
Coming closer. On the left you can see the quad waveshaper, top right the latest (third) PCB for the trapezoid VCO. This one still had some subtle issues. To my surprise it worked not symmetrical with regards to the zero crossing on the lower end of the frequency range. On the "left" side the trapezoid VCO stops working below about 150Hz. On the "right" side everything worked OK. It took me some time to figure out what's going on. Turned out a timing problem when switching the direction of the address rotation. I hopefully fixed it with some additional circuitry (on breadboard). Waiting now for the next PCB.

Haralds:Werk
Coming soon.



B0bcat
I want to express interest in a Euro version smile
MUFF WIGGLER Forum Index -> Music Tech DIY Goto page 1, 2  Next [all]
Page 1 of 2
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group