MUFF WIGGLER Forum Index
 FAQ & Terms of UseFAQ & Terms Of Use   Wiggler RadioMW Radio   Muff Wiggler TwitterTwitter   Support the site @ PatreonPatreon 
 SearchSearch   RegisterSign up   Log inLog in 
WIGGLING 'LITE' IN GUEST MODE

TV/Monitor choices
MUFF WIGGLER Forum Index -> Video Synthesis Goto page 1, 2  Next [all]
Author TV/Monitor choices
fletch
I was thinking of picking up a new LCD TV for working on video synth stuff, but I work in a tv broadcast facility and there are lots of broadcast CRT monitors sitting around that are up for grabs. I like how much space you save with new tvs but since the video signal is composite it might make more sense to go with a CRT. I noticed Lars using some CRT monitors in the NAMM video, they do look good but can be so big/heavy for how much screen you get. What do you guys use?
lizlarsen
I prefer the big broadcast CRTs just out of principle, since they are analog -- with cheaper LCDs you get some bandwidth problems and digital encoding problems (although broadcast LCDs probably wouldn't have this issue.) I have a couple small (7" and 3") LCDs I use for preview monitors... useful for gigs where the main output is going to a projector.
johnnywoods
I have an LCD, and have never had any problems. The glow from a CRT is nice, but I work primarily with hardware upscaling to HD from my LZX, and until I can get my hands on an HD CRT, the LCD is better for my purposes.
xart
fletch wrote:
I was thinking of picking up a new LCD TV for working on video synth stuff, but I work in a tv broadcast facility and there are lots of broadcast CRT monitors sitting around that are up for grabs. I like how much space you save with new tvs but since the video signal is composite it might make more sense to go with a CRT. I noticed Lars using some CRT monitors in the NAMM video, they do look good but can be so big/heavy for how much screen you get. What do you guys use?


a big old CRT here. thumbs up

barto
ive been able to find some old broadcast CRT's either at a local electronics recycler (can be risky, one was clearly used as a weather forecast monitor as i can see screen burn from all the cities in my area) and even found a couple for free on craigslists (just serviced last year!). i like them because most have multiple input chanels as well as input types (bnc, svideo) and loop through. i have 4 19 inchers which are beasts and rarely bring them for live performances but i love having those bad boys stacked at my house (another benefit of broadcast CRT's IMO). i have a couple smaller ones that ive used too which are nice. recently a friend got rid of a 20" LCD which has been kind of perfect for me because its so much smaller and has a handle. i just got a 42" LCD to replace my computer monitor and am definitely planning on bringing that out some time.
MrDys
I use my iMac monitor. My video goes directly into capture and I view it on the monitor. It works for me. The only thing that would improve it is a better capture device, which I should work on getting...

I also have one of those crappy 12" CRT TVs, for when I feel like escaping from my office, and that works as well.
nickciontea


19" crt here
barto
wcfields wrote:
To save space, you can get a used Security Camera Multiplexer and have one monitor that will display any combo of inputs.


lower right TV in my previous post Rawk! found it for 3$ and its great! you can freeze frame, view each source at full screen, and do color/contrast adjustments to each. i also found a way to remove the camera labels and borders. be careful when shopping for one as a lot of them are b/w only.

i really want to build a portable case to store my video mixer, multiplexer and a monitor for live stuff
fletch
cool! I think I'm gonna haul out a behemoth Sony Trinitron I found in the basement at work. It'll be a bit of a workout, but worth it I think.
daverj


Sony Trinitrons are great.

These are 8 of the flat face Trinitron CRTs. I also have a pair of pro Sonys, a couple of small CRTs and LCDs for portable and preview monitors, and a large Sharp HD LCD.

The problem with some HD LCDs (and projectors) is that the scaling circuits in them can get fooled by oscillators that flicker at certain frequencies, such as frame rate or 1/2 frame rate. This can cause the flicker to stop flickering, or some almost frame buffer delay style effects because of the motion correction in the circuits. Not that those look bad, but that they don't accurately show what you'll see on a different monitor.
kjellb
Question for you Dave. I have had LCD panels and projectors freak out from flicker video. So I always try to get CRT monitors for my performances. In theory will certain resolutions work better with composite video than others? And what about the contrast ratio of projectors?
daverj
The contrast ratio of projectors shouldn't have any effect on the flicker issue. And each new generation of LCD and projector has better and better contrast ratios.

I think the main issue with the flicker problem in LCDs and projectors is in the chip set used to do the scaling from standard def to HD. The same chip sets are often used in different resolution screens/projectors, just using different internal settings. So just going on resolution I don't think would be enough to find ones that have less of a problem.

The problem probably comes from the chips trying to remove motion artifacts in their conversion. Since different chip sets do this in different ways, some chip sets probably have more problems than others. Many LCD makers don't make the chips, and just buy them separately, so even within one brand of LCD you might find different brands of scaling chips in different models of monitor/projector.

So I don't think there's a simple solution to solving the problem. It wouldn't be easy, but I would suggest trying out as many scan converters as you can to do the conversion to HD separately from the monitor or projector. If you can find a scan converter (upscaler) that doesn't eliminate the flicker, then you should be able to use that with most LCDs and projectors without the LCD or projector using their internal upscaler and causing the problem. Though there might still be some projectors that re-scale even HD signals into their own native display resolution.

What you want is something that does the line doubling or upscaling, but doesn't have the motion correction function.
BananaPlug
wcfields wrote:
Ideally you'd want to get a Sony Trinitron CRT... The "HR" models (High resolution) can do 600 lines.

Actually 800 lines is the spec on the later ones. I've got a PVM14-M4u. They have so many different inputs! accepts NTSC, NTSC (4.43), PAL, SECAM in Composite, Y/C and RGB, and Y/R-Y/B-Y formats. Many years of incremental improvements in that line of gear.
fletch
picked it up from work...looks great.
Juxwl
creatorlars wrote:
I prefer the big broadcast CRTs just out of principle, since they are analog -- with cheaper LCDs you get some bandwidth problems and digital encoding problems (although broadcast LCDs probably wouldn't have this issue.) I have a couple small (7" and 3") LCDs I use for preview monitors... useful for gigs where the main output is going to a projector.


I watched your NAMM video on Sonicstate. What small LCDs are you using?
lizlarsen
The one I had sitting on top of the case at NAMM was a 7" portable monitor designed I believe for installation in cars or vans. It has built-in speakers and also an internal battery, which is nice. I'm not sure on the brand, but I can check. Tons of options at dealextreme.com just search "LCD monitor".
Juxwl
Thanks Lars. I think I'm gonna order this one:
http://www.dealextreme.com/p/portable-7-tft-lcd-monitor-auto-pal-secam -ntsc-108744
snufkin
I have some big hantarex and some lil sony

it pays to work as an AV tech in a place that is continually upgrading smile
Juxwl
Juxwl wrote:
Thanks Lars. I think I'm gonna order this one:
http://www.dealextreme.com/p/portable-7-tft-lcd-monitor-auto-pal-secam -ntsc-108744


Just wanted to update fellow wigglers and recommend against this monitor. Still have not received it (may be discontinued) and deal extreme are completely unresponsive about the status. Looking into a different one.....
lizlarsen
That's too bad. I remember it taking me 3 weeks or so to get a monitor I ordered from them, but I did receive it eventually.
Orbless
daverj wrote:


Are those 7200's or 7400's?

My vote goes for Sony PVM's as an ideal monitor



We call the small one on the left 'the frog' the next two are normally used as test monitors and the rest primarily exhibition only.
barto
theres some good panasonic and jvc monitors that are stackable that work well too
wcfields
I had a big long post that got deleted when I was cash-grabbing for posts, but I'll try to reiterate what I said.

For production:
8" - 13" Sony Broadcast Monitors (eBay search for "SONY PVM-"), these can be obtained for a reasonable price surplus and they support RGBs, Component, S-Video, and Composite on both NTSC, PAL, and SECAM. Some even support SDI! Even cheaper are older Sony Trinitrons that can be easily found at Goodwills/Salvation Armys.


For presentation:
I'm a huge fan of block style monitors that were extensively used in art galleries before flat screens. These screen still cost a grip unless you find some warehouse/gallery that just wants them gone.

http://the-block.org/ is a rental company that has them in the UK and has a super minimal monitor-porneqe web site.


Sony 29" Cube


Hantarex EQ/3 28"
wcfields
Juxwl wrote:
Juxwl wrote:
Thanks Lars. I think I'm gonna order this one:
http://www.dealextreme.com/p/portable-7-tft-lcd-monitor-auto-pal-secam -ntsc-108744


Just wanted to update fellow wigglers and recommend against this monitor. Still have not received it (may be discontinued) and deal extreme are completely unresponsive about the status. Looking into a different one.....


Did you ever end of receiving it? I've heard that a few times about DE that the waiting period is a-la the old days of catalog ordering (4-6 weeks).
Juxwl
wcfields wrote:
Juxwl wrote:
Juxwl wrote:
Thanks Lars. I think I'm gonna order this one:
http://www.dealextreme.com/p/portable-7-tft-lcd-monitor-auto-pal-secam -ntsc-108744


Just wanted to update fellow wigglers and recommend against this monitor. Still have not received it (may be discontinued) and deal extreme are completely unresponsive about the status. Looking into a different one.....


Did you ever end of receiving it? I've heard that a few times about DE that the waiting period is a-la the old days of catalog ordering (4-6 weeks).


No, and since they weren't responding to my update requests, paypal refunded my money back.
MUFF WIGGLER Forum Index -> Video Synthesis Goto page 1, 2  Next [all]
Page 1 of 2
Powered by phpBB © phpBB Group